The Pros and Cons of Extended Auto Warranties: Are They Worth It?

The Pros and Cons of Extended Auto Warranties: Are They Worth It?
| By: Christian Brothers Automotive

An extended auto warranty is a service contract that provides additional coverage for vehicle repairs and maintenance beyond the original manufacturer's warranty. It typically covers mechanical breakdowns and certain repairs after the original warranty expires, extending protection for a specified period or mileage, whichever comes first.

These warranties are sold separately from the vehicle, often by third-party companies or dealerships, and come in various levels of coverage, from basic powertrain to comprehensive bumper-to-bumper protection. Christian Brothers Automotive is here to walk you through the benefits and drawbacks of these warranties and to offer advice on what factors you should consider before investing in an extended auto warranty.

Pros & Cons of an Extended Warranty

The pros of an extended warranty include the following:

  • Greater Peace of Mind: Knowing you're covered for unexpected repairs can reduce stress and alleviate the worry of having to pay for costly fixes out of pocket. This can be especially valuable for those who rely on their vehicle for work or important daily tasks.
  • Cost Predictability: You can budget for a fixed warranty cost rather than unpredictable repair bills. This makes it easier to plan your automotive expenses and avoid financial surprises.
  • Potential Savings: If major repairs are needed, the warranty could save you significant money compared to paying for those repairs out of pocket. This is especially true for high-cost components like the engine, transmission, or advanced electronics.
  • Convenience and Added Benefits: Many warranties offer perks like roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and trip interruption benefits. These added services can make dealing with breakdowns and repairs much more manageable.
  • Transferability: Some warranties can be transferred if you sell your car, potentially increasing its value. This can be an attractive selling point and make your vehicle more appealing on the used market.

Conversely, the potential downsides to making this purchase include:

  • Upfront Cost: Extended warranties can be expensive, and you might never use them. Weighing the cost of the warranty against the potential repair bills is crucial.
  • Limited Coverage: Many warranties have exclusions and may not cover all types of repairs. While you may think you are covered for all repairs or even just all costly repairs, you may not be. It's important to thoroughly review the terms and conditions to understand exactly what is and isn't covered.
  • Claim Disputes: There can be disagreements over what's covered, leading to frustration.
  • Reliability Factor: Modern cars are often reliable enough that extended coverage may not be necessary. Doing research on the specific make and model's track record can help determine if the added cost is worthwhile.
  • Overlap: The warranty might overlap with the manufacturer's warranty, providing redundant coverage that doesn't necessarily add value. Careful comparison is needed to avoid paying for duplicative protection.
  • Depreciation: As your car loses value, expensive repairs become less economically sensible. At a certain point, it may make more financial sense to simply replace the vehicle rather than pour money into repairs.

What to Consider Before Getting a Dealership’s Extended Warranty Plan

If you are offered an extended auto warranty, consider the following before making the investment:

  • Vehicle Reliability: Research your car's make and model for common issues and overall dependability and compare the common issues with the coverage options included in the extended warranty.
  • Existing Coverage: Check your current manufacturer's warranty to avoid overlap.
  • Ownership Duration: Consider how long you plan to keep the vehicle.
  • Driving Habits: Factor in your annual mileage and typical driving conditions.
  • Cost vs. Value: Compare the warranty price to potential repair costs and your budget.
  • Deductibles: Understand any out-of-pocket costs for covered repairs.
  • Claims Process: Learn how repairs are approved and where they can be performed. Consider seeking outside opinions instead of asking the dealer directly. Other customers’ experiences with trying to get repairs can inform whether you want to make this investment.
  • Provider Reputation: Research the warranty company's customer service and claim handling.
  • Negotiability: Remember that warranty prices are often negotiable, unlike car prices. See how willing the dealer is to negotiate and if you can get terms that better fit your needs.
  • Cancellation Policy: Check if you can cancel the warranty and receive a prorated refund.
  • Vehicle Age and Mileage: Consider these factors, as older or high-mileage vehicles may benefit more.
  • Transferability: Determine if the warranty can be transferred to a new owner if you sell the car. As this is one of the pros of extended auto warranties, you want to make sure you get this benefit before counting it as a reason to get a warranty.
  • Alternative Options: Compare dealership offers with third-party warranties and self-insurance.

Not Interested in the Dealership’s Extended Warranty? Consider Ours.

Christian Brothers Automotive offers the Nice Difference Warranty, a comprehensive coverage option for auto repairs, ensuring peace of mind for customers. This warranty stands out by providing protection for 3 years or 36,000 miles, whichever occurs last, unlike typical warranties that expire at the first limit reached. This means that if it takes longer to reach the mileage limit, the warranty remains valid, offering extended protection against defects in new parts and improper installation.

Our warranty is valid nationwide across all of our locations, allowing customers to receive service even when traveling. Find your local Christian Brothers Automotive!

Find Your Closest Christian Brothers Automotive Location Today

Find a Location
  • "Honesty in Spades"

    "I am visiting from Missouri and needed some work completed on my truck. Christian Brothers was highly recommended. While my truck was being worked on a small amount of damage was done to it. As soon ..."

    Tim Kuelker

  • "I want to thank Christian Brothers"

    "I have found a great place to have my car repaired a little late but they are great at the"Ocotillo" Chandler, AZ, location. I recently have had a turn down in health. My wife is now in charge of ..."

    James A Miller

  • "Fantastic Customer Service!!!"

    "I have NEVER received such great customer service than what I received with Christian Brothers!! Being a women, it’s not easy walking into a car service place, but Jake and all the staff that I talked ..."

    Patti Beckwith