The Pros & Cons of Rebuilding Vs. Replacing a Defective Transmission

The Pros & Cons of Rebuilding Vs. Replacing a Defective Transmission

| By: Christian Brothers Automotive

A transmission is one of your vehicle’s most critical and expensive mechanical components. It enables you to change gears smoothly while driving, which is necessary for a comfortable ride. However, like any other machine, it is susceptible to wear and tear and, therefore, requires rebuilding or replacement.

At Christian Brothers Automotive Spring Klein (Stuebner), we've seen countless defective transmissions. Our technicians have the knowledge, technologies, and skill set to troubleshoot and isolate issues and recommend multiple options moving forward. If you’re dealing with a severe malfunction, we will present every choice honestly and transparently and let you weigh the pros and cons of rebuilding vs. replacing your transmission.

The Lifespan of a Transmission

When considering whether to rebuild or replace your transmission, you may wonder how long a transmission tends to last. The typical transmission lifespan varies from vehicle to vehicle, with some lasting up to 200,000 miles or more. However, if you own a car prone to strain, like a pickup or SUV model, or drive aggressively, your transmission may wear out faster.

Sings of a Defective or Failing Transmission

A key clue when investigating a flailing transmission is the scent of burning transmission fluid, which has an aroma with undertones of burnt toast. The smell can be pungent and odorous in some circumstances and feint in others. If you detect a burning smell, your transmission may be overheating, and you need to pull over and get it checked immediately. Transmission fluid is essential for keeping your transmission lubricated and cool. As a result, any unusual burning smell may indicate a hazardous situation.

Other obvious signs of issues with your transmission include how your car behaves while driving. If your transmission is failing, your vehicle may jerk or vibrate, especially when shifting gears. You may also notice your car hesitating to accelerate or not shifting into gear, which could signal severe transmission problems. We recommend taking your vehicle to a professional mechanic to diagnose your transmission if you notice any warning signs.

Treat Your Transmission with Proactive Maintenance and Repairs

If you notice a transmission defect early, our mechanics may be able to perform preventative repairs and maintenance. By acting quickly, we can salvage your poorly functioning transmission without breaking the bank. Our team has the equipment and experience to inspect and fix isolated issues and faulty components that commonly create transmission problems.

One of the significant benefits of receiving proactive maintenance is that it can save you money in the long run. Regular visits and inspections can help our expert car specialists spot minor defects, such as solenoid replacements or external leaks. However, repairs only succeed when damage is isolated to a specific area. It’s critical to understand that a defect can indicate underlying issues, which may require further attention in the near future.

Transmission Broken Beyond Repair? It Is Time to Decide Whether to Rebuild or Replace

When it comes to considering whether to rebuild or replace your transmission, there are pros and cons for both options. Rebuilding a transmission is typically less expensive than replacing it, allowing you to cut costs while extending its lifespan. During the rebuilding process, our technicians will remove the transmission, disassemble it, identify issues, and replace any worn or damaged parts.

Rebuilding can be cost-effective compared to replacing the entire transmission. If the rebuilt transmission operates correctly, you’ll enjoy smoother gear transitions, better fuel economy, and a longer lifespan for your car.

There are also some downsides to rebuilding your transmission. It usually takes much longer to rebuild a transmission than to replace one. Many transmission malfunctions are also beyond the point of repair. Lastly, rebuilt transmissions will still contain older parts, which may fall into disrepair sooner than anticipated.

Alternatively, replacing your transmission may cost more, but you get the benefits of a brand-new transmission free of wear and tear. A new transmission should perform smoothly, seamlessly, and durably. Replacing your transmission also makes more sense if your vehicle is older or has many miles.

Our Automobile Experts Are Eager to Assist

Lastly, buying a new car may be your wisest solution if your vehicle's transmission is beyond repair, and rebuilding or replacing it is worth more than the vehicle. Although this option is the most expensive, it guarantees a better-performing car and offers a fresh start. With a new car, you’ll likely enjoy many years without recurring transmission problems or other expensive repairs associated with old age.

Of course, some car owners may remain committed to their vehicles, regardless of cost-benefit analyses. Whatever decision you ultimately make, Christian Brothers Automotive Spring Klein (Stuebner) is here to help you carefully weigh every outcome. We can also perform expert car transmission inspections, repairs, rebuilds, and replacements. Our auto mechanics are on your side, helping you make informed decisions to maximize short-term and long-term upsides. We are here to help you enjoy a healthy car with a fully functioning transmission!

Are you dealing with transmission problems? Call (281) 771-0517 today!

Related Articles

Schedule an Appointment with Your Local Christian Brothers Automotive Location Today

Schedule An Appointment
Read Our Reviews
  • Facebook
  • Google My Business
  • "CBA Spring stueber is my auto repair shop for life!"

    "I was so impressed with this new CBA! The staff is super friendly and helpful, kept me informed on the progress of my brake job and showed me photos of the parts that needed attention. The lobby has ..."

    Ted Seago

  • "A place you can trust"

    "I have used them tWice, 100k mile maintenance. They have done a wonderful job."

    Gery landrum

  • "0"

    "I was very impressed with my experience here they did a great job very professional . i would highly recommend this location and they have a new customer for life."

    scott webster